Illawarra: Reeves, Seru, Timmins, Rodwell, Clifford, Barrett, Air, Cross (c), Mackay, Bristow, Smith, Robinson, Bradstreet. Res: Cram, Cox, David.
Manly: Hancock, Moore, Innes, Hill, Hopoate, Toovey (c), Field, Kosef, Serdaris, Menzies, Carroll, S Fulton, Tierney. Res: Weepu, Hunter Lyons.
FootyTAB: Illawarra +13.5
The Magpies led early, but a Terry Hill try in the 32nd minute brought it back to 4-4 at the break. With 24 minutes to go in the game, Wests had rushed to a 16-4 lead, but a spirited Manly fightback through tries to Menzies and Lyons saw it brought back to 17-16 with just 3 minutes remaining. A late goal to Andrew Leeds sealed the win for Wests, however, the Magpies finding themselves unlikely winners.
The Eagles blew several chances, with dropped balls on that last pass proving the difference. It was a costly loss for Manly - star forward Daniel Gartner has broken his thumb, and will be out for four to six weeks. With further injuries to David Gillespie and Nik Kosef, and Craig Hancock, Terry Hill and Mark Carroll all placed on report, it was not a happy afternoon for the Manly side. The only comfort to be had from the outing was a pair of wins to the lower grade sides.
It was at least pleasing to see the Eagles attempt to cut back on their backchat to the referee. John Hopoate still managed to get in his now trademark ``head-pat'', this time on former team-mate Des Hasler. Not good enough, John. Stick to playing football.
Manly still lead the competition after eight rounds, two points ahead of Newcastle. Their next game is on Sunday afternoon down at Wollongong, when they take on the Steelers.
The teams for Sunday's game against Western Suburbs are as follows:
Wests: Leeds, Willlis, Ken McGuinness, Pearson, Laing, Kevin McGuinness, Georgalis, Langmack (c), Millard, Dunn, Skandalis, Mescia, Howard. Res: Hasler, Doyle, Smith.
Manly: Hancock, Moore, Innes, Hill, Hopoate, Toovey (c), Field, Kosef, Gartner, Menzies, Carroll, Scott Fulton, Tierney. Res: Weepu, Hunter, Lyons.
FootyTAB: Wests +14.5
Next Sunday the unstoppable Eagles travel to Campbelltown to take on the Magpies, for what is always a rough encounter.
Newcastle: O'Davis, Albert, MacDougall, Craigie, Gidley, M Johns(c), Dynevor, Glanville, Muir, Peden, Richards, Jackson, Butterfield. Reserves: Harragon, Fletcher, Moodie.
FootyTAB: Newcastle +8.5
Manly return to Brookvale next Sunday for a top of the table clash against the Newcastle Knights. Another win can make it seven wins in a row and put the Eagles at least three points clear at the top of the ladder.
Jim Serdaris and David Gillespie are still out with injuries.
The Eagles are now alone, undefeated, at the top of the table after five rounds. On Saturday night they travel to Parramatta to take on the struggling Eels.
Question for the week: when will Steve Menzies score a try?
Earlier stories: [Jan 97 | Feb 97 | Mar 97]